We rate Windows 10 and Windows 8.1 in a lot of key categories for professional users
Windows 10 premiered three years ago, and even though many users initially resisted the advance, it’s most definitely maturing all the time. As always though, you will find die-hard fans of previous os’s who have yet to help make the jump.
Time is depleted, however; Microsoft is expired mainstream support for the best recent major type of Windows 8.1, with extended support by reason of cut off in January 2023. If you happen to haven’t updated to Windows 10, it won’t be for too long before you’re no longer able to do so safely.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Boot time
We’ve found no apparent improvement in boot times backward and forward OS, at a minimum not on both of the computers we intended for this test: a Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon and then a Microsoft Surface Pro. Both laptops booted in to the login screen in eight seconds, under both Windows 8.1 and Windows 10; just fractions of any second’s difference between the boot points during the the two OSes on either machine.
Characteristic that may potentially shave a matter of seconds off real-world boot times is Windows 10’s facial recognition tool, which a user to generally be logged during the minute they sit next to their PC. This selection, however, ingests a special Intel RealSense 3D camera – and does not work with an ordinary webcam. Besides fingerprint readers, these cameras turn out to be relatively common in high-end notebooks, offers Windows 10 a slight edge.
Windows 10, from their whisker, but only if you count your little friend potential time saving of facial recognition.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Interface
Clearly, Windows 8’s initial insistence on imposing the tiled Start screen on devices that didn’t also have a touchscreen ruined any chance for the computer system ever getting widespread business adoption. Although the error was partially corrected by Windows 8.1, when desktop computer and laptop users could boot with the desktop and pretend inception screen didn’t exist, it was subsequently still important for many core functions from launching apps to changing settings.
Windows 10 puts that right, albeit when using an imperfect hybrid of one’s Windows 7 Start menu and Windows 8 Start screen. On desktops and laptops, the beginning menu emerges out of the bottom-left corner among the screen, with most-used programs listed the left-hand side, having a link to an A-Z menu of all installed apps, as you move right-hand side shows the Live Tiles of your respective Windows 8 era. On tablets, it works very much like the way it did under Windows 8.1, utilizing the Live Tiles expanding to dominate your whole screen.
We still think there’s try to be done with tiled section of the Start menu. With four different tile sizes as well as awkward drag-and-drop system, it’s too effortless end up with an untidy, gap-strewn mish-mash of tiles.
And once you’ve got quite a lot of live tiles activated, your screen starting to look like a Las vegas, nv casino, getting a wall of rotating, scrolling squares each hoping to catch your eye. Yet, it’s undoubtedly a noticeable difference on what went before for non-touchscreen devices.
Other notable new additions can be the Cortana search bar in the bottom left in the Taskbar. We’ll talk more details on Cortana later, however, the search bar enables enter voice or typed mission to find apps or files stored on your laptop. You can go through the My Stuff button looking results to perform more complex searches of one’s files, which certainly makes it easier to find specific files than by using Windows 8.1. However, we still discover it is easier to instigate advanced searches from the inside Files Explorer (called Windows Explorer in 8.1) and it’s hugely disappointing that Outlook emails aren’t integrated into searches.
Talking of Files Explorer, that’s kept a refresh too. Except for a stark new kind of icons, Explorer has a Quick Access view which shows your most frequently opened folders presents itself the window, having a list of recently accessed files just under, making it easier to quickly buy where you left off on files which could be nested deep in folders.
You can still pin your favourite folders for the left-hand pane of Files Explorer, but this does create some duplication using frequent folders pane just with it, although the Libraries first introduced in Windows 7 are actually almost hidden from view. Your new Explorer could be a modest improvement on Windows 8.1’s, purchased needs refinement.
One significant new interface element for businesses is virtual desktops. An idea brazenly lifted coming from the Linux world, Windows 10’s virtual desktops make you keep different teams of apps open diverse desktops. You can, for example, have one desktop focused upon communications (with, say, Outlook, Slack and Skype running) and yet another for handle a particular project (Excel in addition to a web browser). It allows you to compartmentalise your task, and avoid having desktops cluttered with several keep the windows open, but it’s frustrating that a great many apps formulated to run full-screen within the touchscreen is only able to occupy unique desktop.
Windows 10 corrects nearly all of Windows 8’s ills with all the Start screen, whilst revamped file management and virtual desktops are potential productivity boosters. An outright victory for desktop and laptop users.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Stability
While it was the actual overhaul about the OS since Windows 95, Windows 8 was remarkably stable and bug-free on the get-go. Indeed, there was it running on everyday work systems half a year before launch.
Windows 10 might be, to put it charitably, a tad wobblier. Microsoft is regularly issuing updates for a software, but these updates often behave badly. It seems like every few months there are new reports of accidental file deletions, glitches, crashes along with other assorted errors. General stability is simply better than this became, but the notion that these errors persist is frustrating.
Thus far, we haven’t seen any bugs that we’d consider enough to warrant downgrading a strong earlier version of Windows, but it has to be mentioned that reliability isn’t Windows 10’s strong suit – and it doesn’t be similar to it ever shall be. On the other hand, Windows 10 Enterprise users can cut out countless this headache – which we’ll have a discussion about more in a minute – meaning it’s not necessarily quite so much of an issue.
Windows 8.1. Businesses can select to skip much of the issues designed by Windows 10’s rolling updates, although the fact that they be forced to in the first place is hardly encouraging.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Enterprise features
Windows 8.1 actually did an excellent amount of spadework for business users. Features as an example Secure Boot, Windows To get information (giving you a bootable desktop from your USB stick), and Hyper-V virtualisation of guest OSes were features possess overshadowed by the focus on touchscreen devices.
Those features stay in Windows 10, generally there are others that is going to have a hugely significant affect business rollouts. In-place upgrades are made much smoother, meaning IT managers won’t want to wipe and reimage once they may have done before. On our ThinkPad rich in business-oriented desktop apps (Office 2013, Slack, Creative Suite as well as others), we performed an in-place upgrade to Windows 10 Pro in less than 40 minutes, with all of documents, applications and settings perfectly retained.
Microsoft can also making it quite easy for IT managers to create off-the-shelf hardware into businesses, with new runtime configuration tools that should implement VPN settings, e-mail profiles, app installations and security policies without wiping the hardware and starting afresh.
Microsoft been specifically commendably wary of forcing businesses to attach the same rolling updates to Windows 10 that happens to be now mandatory for consumers, this kind of tool no longer opt from Windows Updates. Enterprise users can go for a Long Term Servicing Branch in the OS – another idea pinched from Linux – allowing them to put in a stable type of Windows 10 on mission-critical machines, that would only receive essential security updates without the new features that may be periodically presented to regular Windows 10 users. Windows 10 Pro users, meanwhile, can defer updates, giving extra features a few months to bed down on consumer systems before they’re applied to a business machine.
Windows 10. Windows 8 didn’t find the credit it deserved for enterprise features, but Windows 10 expands them far more and makes rollouts a smaller headache for departments.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Security
Controversial even as it was, due to the way it shut out some Linux distros, Windows 8’s Secure Boot eliminated the threat of several harmful samples of malware. It’s also the first form of Windows to ship with built-in antivirus protection, no matter if Windows Defender does routinely perform poorly in Dennis Technology Labs’ independent tests.
With Windows 10, Microsoft is popping the screw even tighter with Secure Boot, giving PC manufacturers pre-owned to prevent users disabling the feature. As opposed to upset consumers who need to dual-boot OSes, but the vast majority of business machines will simply ever boot directly into OS the device is shipped with, as well as prevents almost any chance of malicious rootkits every other low-level malware infecting the boot process.
By adding face and iris recognition within the list of user authentication options already within Windows 8 potentially adds extra convenience for the users therefore departments alike (unlike passwords or smartcards, nobody forgets their face). However, both require specialised hardware, nor is common enough will probably be universal standard yet.
Windows 10 edges to increase its predecessor, even so the new authentication options still haven’t fully caught on.
Windows 10 vs Windows 8.1: Mobility
Windows 8.1 is already a pretty decent tablet OS, hampered usually by a poor obvious high-quality apps inside Windows Store. At this time, it’s hard to tell if Microsoft’s new Windows 10 coverage for Universal Apps – apps operating across PC, tablet and phones – will bear fruit, but Windows 10 has already been a better tablet OS than its predecessor.
A good reason for this is Continuum, which automatically adapts the Windows 10 interface to install the mode it’s active in on hybrid devices. Detach a computer device such as the Surface by reviewing the keyboard, and Windows 10 prompts yourself to enter Tablet Mode, where the Start menu spans the overall screen, the Taskbar disappears, apps run fully screen and not windows, therefore you effectively get no access toward the desktop.
Reattach the laptop keyboard, and the Start menu shrinks back to its corner, the Taskbar springs back, and apps might be run in whatever proportions window you finally choose, even touchscreen-focussed apps through the Windows Store. It’s an excellent feature, possibly the best Windows 10 provides, and a real boon for hybrid devices, making the shifting between modes feel much smoother and for you to feel like two distinct devices. Our only gripe is that often Windows 10 doesn’t always recognise a modification of mode if you’ve, say, detached a keyboard whilst device was switched off. However, you can actually activate and deactivate Tablet Mode manually over the new Action Center.
Windows 10 also introduces a cell Saver mode, dimming the screen and cutting needless notifications to preserve life cycle of battery. It automatically starts when the battery dips below 20%, however can apply the mode manually, too. It’s not most likely to add hours to the laptop’s/tablet’s run time, but every little helps.
An emphatic victory for Windows 10, which finally seems logical of hybrid devices, and adds limited battery saving benefits.
It’s not perfect and it’s now a perpetual work in progress, but Windows 10 demonstrates Microsoft can make do with what many thought impossible: a practical system that sits comfortably on desktops, laptops and tablets.
Windows 8 and 8.1 now look like the prototypes Microsoft needed to work through to seek out an operating system that done all three brands of computer, whereas in the many ways it’s a shame that process was necessary in public, but Microsoft’s not only heard the howls of complaint about Windows 8, but acted upon them.
If businesses rightly shied beyond your Windows 8, you are able to see few attorney shun its successor. The very beginning menu is less jarring and intimidating than its Start screen predecessor, the migration path is smoother an income are numerous security and productivity benefits. Blood circulation kinks, we would wholeheartedly recommend upgrading both existing equipment and pre-installing Windows 10 on new machines.